Ypsilanti might sit in the shadow of Ann Arbor’s food scene, but locals know this town punches far above its weight when it comes to pizza. If you’re craving pizza by the slice in Ypsi, one name comes up over and over again: Mama Pizza on North Hamilton. From ultra-affordable cheese slices to wildly inventive curry-fusion toppings, it has become a must-visit stop for students, neighbors, and hungry visitors alike.
Table of Contents
Why Mama Pizza Stands Out in Ypsi
Mama Pizza (also listed as Mama Pizza & Curry House) at 5 N Hamilton St, Ypsilanti, MI 48197 has quietly built a cult following. What began as a small counter-service pizzeria has become one of the most talked-about slice shops in town, thanks to three key strengths: price, creativity, and consistency.
First, the value is hard to beat. Mama Pizza advertises budget-friendly slices (their site lists $1.50 pizza slices for basic options), making it a go-to for Eastern Michigan University students and anyone grabbing a quick lunch downtown. You can walk in, order a slice or two, and be out the door for less than the cost of a fancy coffee.
Second, the menu is genuinely unique. Instead of sticking only to standard pepperoni and deluxe pies, Mama Pizza leans into its curry-house side, offering Indian-inspired pizzas that you simply won’t find at a typical corner slice shop. The restaurant highlights signature fusion items such as Chicken Tikka Masala pizza, Paneer Tikka Masala pizza, and Samosa Pizza on its menu, alongside Indian street-food like Masala Dosa and Samosa Chaat.
Finally, online reviews and local listings consistently highlight friendly service and reliable quality. Many reviewers mention that the owners remember repeat customers and are happy to walk newcomers through the more adventurous toppings. That personal touch has helped turn a small shop into a beloved neighborhood staple. (See the Mama Pizza website for menu, hours and contact.)
Signature Slices to Try at Mama Pizza
One of the biggest perks of a slice shop is the ability to sample different flavors without committing to an entire pie. Mama Pizza makes that especially fun with a menu that ranges from classic to downright bold.
Classic and Detroit-Style Favorites
If you like to start simple, you’ll find:
- Cheese Slice – A great way to test the fundamentals: crust, sauce, and cheese. Locals praise the balance of tangy sauce and well-melted cheese.
- Pepperoni Slice – Crispy edges, generous pepperoni, and a satisfying amount of cheese make this a dependable go-to.
- Detroit-Style Options – Mama Pizza offers Detroit-style pies on its menu; when available by the slice, they deliver that thick, airy crust and caramelized cheese edge that Detroit pizza fans love.
Curry-Fusion Creations
Where Mama Pizza really separates itself is in its curry fusion pizzas. These are the slices that put the shop on the map for adventurous eaters:
- Chicken Tikka Masala Pizza – Tender chicken marinated in tikka spices, a creamy masala-inspired sauce, and fresh herbs. This is listed on the restaurant’s menu.
- Paneer Tikka Pizza – A vegetarian favorite featuring paneer (Indian cheese), peppers, onions, and tikka spices. Mama Pizza lists paneer options on its vegetarian-friendly menu.
- Samosa Pizza – Think of the flavors of a potato-filled samosa—spiced potatoes, peas, and chutney-style notes—spread across a cheesy base. This is one of the signature items promoted by the shop.
- Bombay or Pav Bhaji-Inspired Pizzas – Some delivery and listing pages note Bombay- or Pav Bhaji-style pizzas among rotating specialty pies; expect bold spices and a vegetable-forward topping mix when available.
Because toppings and slice availability can rotate, it’s worth asking what’s fresh on the counter when you walk in. If you’re ordering online, delivery platforms usually show a dedicated “By The Slice” section or list current specials.
Vibe, Location, and Value
Mama Pizza is a casual, counter-service spot. You order at the counter, grab your slices, and either take them to go or settle in for a quick bite. The interior is simple and functional—more about the food than the décor—which suits its role as a downtown slice stop.
Its location on North Hamilton puts you close to Downtown Ypsilanti and Depot Town, making it an easy add-on to a day of exploring local shops, coffee spots, and the Huron River area. Parking is typically street-based, so give yourself a few extra minutes during busier times.
Hours listed on the restaurant’s site show Mon–Fri 11:00 AM–9:00 PM; Sat–Sun 12:00 PM–9:00 PM; closed Tuesdays, but hours can change for holidays or special events—check the shop’s site or call ahead at (734) 896-3843 before you go.
From a budget standpoint, Mama Pizza is one of the best deals in town. Between low-cost slices, combo-style ordering, and hearty toppings, you can easily fill up without emptying your wallet—part of why it’s so popular with students and downtown workers.
Tips for Pizza Lovers Visiting Ypsilanti
If you’re planning a mini pizza tour of Ypsi, a little strategy goes a long way:
- Start with slices at Mama Pizza – Grab a classic slice and one curry-fusion slice to experience both sides of the menu.
- Check hours in advance – Independent shops sometimes adjust hours seasonally or around campus schedules. A quick online check can save you a wasted trip (see each shop’s official site or ordering page).
- Mix styles – Balance Detroit-style, New York-style, and fusion pizzas to get a feel for the range of what Ypsi offers.
- Walk it off downtown – Pair your slices with a stroll through downtown Ypsilanti or along the riverfront. It’s an easy way to explore the city between stops.
- Use delivery apps strategically – If you’re short on time, platforms like Uber Eats, DoorDash, and similar apps can show you current slice availability and specials in one place.
How Mama Pizza Compares to Nearby Options
When you line up Ypsilanti’s pizza options side by side, Mama Pizza occupies a distinctive niche:
- Best for budget slices: Mama Pizza is hard to beat if you want quick, inexpensive slices downtown.
- Most creative toppings: Its curry-fusion menu stands out even compared to other inventive local pizza spots.
- Most traditional sit-down experience: Full-service pizzerias in town are better if you want table service and a full bar, while Mama Pizza shines as a grab-and-go slice shop.
- Best for a quick solo meal: With fast service and plenty of variety by the slice, it’s ideal when you’re eating on your own or on a tight schedule.
If your priority is pizza by the slice in Ypsilanti, especially within walking distance of downtown, Mama Pizza is the clear starting point—and for many locals, the default answer.
FAQ: Pizza by the Slice in Ypsilanti
Yes. Mama Pizza advertises pizza by the slice on its menu and on its ordering pages. You’ll typically find cheese and pepperoni slices, plus rotating specialty and fusion slices depending on what’s fresh.
The restaurant’s website lists $1.50 pizza slices for basic options; specialty slices cost more. Prices can change over time, so check in-store menus or online ordering platforms for current pricing.
Absolutely. Mama Pizza’s Paneer Tikka and various veggie-forward fusion pizzas are popular with vegetarians, and classic cheese slices are almost always available.
The restaurant highlights halal-certified chicken options and positions itself as offering halal-friendly dishes on its site. If halal preparation is important to you, confirm details directly with the restaurant when you order.
If you’re looking for a sit-down experience, consider one of Ypsilanti’s full-service pizzerias or restaurants that specialize in whole pies, appetizers, and drinks. Mama Pizza is better suited to quick meals and takeout.
Yes. Several local pizza shops and independents are known for later hours, often staying open well past typical dinner service. Check each location’s site or delivery listing for current hours.
Downtown Ypsilanti and Depot Town are quite walkable, with several food and drink spots clustered together. You can easily grab slices at Mama Pizza, explore local coffee shops and bars, and then head over to Depot Town for a sit-down meal—all without getting back in the car. For spots farther out, you’ll want to drive.
Whether you’re a student, a local, or just passing through, Ypsilanti offers a surprisingly deep pizza scene for a small city. If you’re starting with slices, though, Mama Pizza is the place that most Ypsi residents will send you first.
